Episode 71 · 27 min · Ghost stories and the Unusual Paranormal podcast

The Blue Lady of Fool Hollow: The Ghost That Won't Leave the Water

Published Sep 14, 2026by Joe the Paranormal DetectiveFolk tales

One candle for every story

  1. 1 - told, candle out
  2. 2 - told, candle out
  3. 3 - told, candle out
  4. 4 - told, candle out
  5. 5 - told, candle out
  6. 6 - told, candle out
  7. 7 - told, candle out
  8. 8 - told, candle out
  9. 9 - told, candle out
  10. 10 - told, candle out
  11. 11 - told, candle out
  12. 12 - told, candle out
  13. 13 - told, candle out
  14. 14 - told, candle out
  15. 15 - told, candle out
  16. 16 - told, candle out
  17. 17 - told, candle out
  18. 18 - told, candle out
  19. 19 - told, candle out
  20. 20 - told, candle out
  21. 21 - told, candle out
  22. 22 - being told, candle burning
  23. 23 - still to tell, candle lit
  24. 24 - still to tell, candle lit

Story 71 of 79. 70 told, 8 still waiting.

Listen to the whole episode

Playing from the creator's feed

Shownotes

About this episode

Beneath the dark surface of Fool Hollow Lake lies a drowned settlement — and, some say, a spirit who never left. In this episode we trace the legend of the Blue Lady: the haunted lake, the sunken town beneath it, and the eerie figure locals claim to have seen drifting along the shoreline. We dig into what she looks like, why she may still linger, the reported encounters that keep the story alive, and the unsettling question at the heart of it all — what does she want? Part folklore, part ghost story, all warning: this is the tale of the ghost that won't leave the water.

Next in the series

Keep going.

Is this your show, or something that should not be here? Report or request removal Copyright and takedown

From Joe the Paranormal Detective · original site